Bullish sentiment measured through the AAII weekly survey was at the lowest level since the fall last week, but after jumping 7.7 percentage points, it is now at the highest level since the end of April. Not only is it high relative to the past few weeks, but the increase also brings bullish sentiment 6 percentage points back above its historical average. Additionally, the week over week increase was the largest since the week of April 8th when the reading had risen 11.1 percentage points.

In recent weeks, neutral sentiment had been surging; topping 37% last week for the highest reading since the first week of 2020.  Although it reversed lower this week down to 36.2%, neutral sentiment remains around some of the strongest levels in over a year.

With the pickup in bullish sentiment, bearish sentiment plummeted to 19.8% on a 6.6 percentage point decile; the largest since February.  Falling below 20%, bearish sentiment took out its March and April lows and is now at the lowest level since January 2018.

Not only is that one of the lowest readings in bearish sentiment in recent history, but that drop below 20% brought to an end a 115-week long streak of readings in bearish sentiment above that level.  As shown below, that surpassed a three-week shorter streak ending in December 2017 to make for the second-longest such streak on record.  The longest streak which ended in December 2010 went on for more than twice as long as this most recent run.

Historically, lower readings in bearish sentiment have tended towards weaker performance for the S&P 500 going forward as shown below.  But when it comes to the past times that bearish sentiment has broken below 20% for the first time in at least 50 weeks, performance has actually tended to consistently be positive. In fact, across each of the past six instances, the S&P 500 has been higher six months out every time. Granted, for the most part the typical move higher is usually smaller than other periods.  Click here to view Bespoke’s premium membership options for our best research available.

It was just the start of last month that initial jobless claims fell below a half million for the first time since the start of the pandemic and a month before that marked the first reading below 600K.  Another month in the books and it was another 100K milestone reached this week. For the first time since the pandemic began, seasonally-adjusted claims fell below 400K to 385K this week.  That is now only 129K above the pre-pandemic level from last March; the last week before claims exploded above a million.

While the drop below 400K may sound like a positive, it was entirely due to the seasonal adjustment as the actual level of claims rose to 425.5K from 419.4K.  That is still at the bottom of the pandemic range albeit slightly off the lows. Additionally, while small,  that week over week uptick is a bit unusual from a historical perspective as the current week of the year (22nd) has only seen a sequential uptick 18.5% of the time since the start of the data in 1967.

In spite of the uptick in regular state programs, claims through the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance program continued to pick up the slack. The program saw another impressive drop with the program only totaling 76.1K claims.  That is down roughly 17.5K from last week and sets more pandemic lows. On a combined basis, initial claims between the two programs now sit just above 500K.

As we have frequently mentioned recently, while initial jobless claims keep coming in with impressive readings, continuing claims remain uninspiring. For the week ending May 21st, claims had risen by 169K to 3.77 million.  That brings continuing claims to the highest level since the week of March 12 and the 169K WoW increase was the largest since the last week of November when they rose 254K.  Overall, the picture at the headline level remains the same in which initial claims are strong and improving while continuing claims have hit a bump in the road.

Whereas the non-seasonally adjusted picture was less positive for initial claims, there is yet another divergence compared to continuing claims.  The NSA continuing claims reading that includes all programs is delayed two additional weeks to the most recent initial claims data. That means the most recent reading in the charts below is for the week of May 14th. That week saw another decline down to new lows of 15.46 million on a combined basis with the biggest contributors to that decline being regular state, PUA, and Extended Benefits programs.  On the other hand, Pandemic Emergency Unemployment Assistance (PEUC) claims held things back as the program saw a 102K increase; bringing it to the highest level since mid-April. That meant PEUC claims’ share of total continuing claims reached the highest level yet at 34.2%. That means although regular state continuing claims have been deteriorating, the broader picture continues to improve.    Click here to view Bespoke’s premium membership options for our best research available.

May has moved back to the rearview mirror and with that, we wanted to provide an update on how current long-term returns for the S&P 500 stack up relative to history.  The chart below compares the trailing one, two, five, ten, and twenty-year annualized total returns of the S&P 500 to the S&P 500’s historical average returns over those same time periods since 1928.

We’re starting to move away from the ‘easy comps’ in terms of market returns relative to the March 2020 lows, but the S&P 500 is still up more than 40% over the last 12 months which is nearly four times the historical average one year return. Over the last two years, the S&P 500’s annualized return of 25.8% still comes in at more than twice the historical average of 10.6%.  On a five and ten-year basis, the S&P 500’s annualized gain also remains comfortably above 10%.  All in all, the last decade has been very good for US equity investors.  The only time period where the S&P 500 has experienced below-average returns is at the 20-year window where the 8.4% annualized gain clocks in at 2.5 percentage less than the historical average of 10.9%.

The chart below compares the S&P 500’s current returns over the last one, two, five, ten, and twenty years to all other periods on a percentile basis.  With mostly above-average returns, it comes as no surprise that most of the percentile readings rank above the 50th percentile, and for most time periods, the percentile rank comes in well above 50%.  The one-year total return of more than 40% actually ranks just above the 93rd percentile, while the two-year return isn’t far from the 90th percentile either.  Moving further out, each of the other readings going out to ten years are all well above the 50th percentile. The only percentile rank below the 50th percentile is the 20-year window and that reading isn’t even close.  On the one hand, the last ten years have been phenomenal for equity investors, but the last 20 years haven’t even been mediocre.

Throughout history, many investors have always worked under the assumption that long-term returns for the equity market are about 10%.  History has shown that to be the case over the last decade at least, as the average annualized one-year gain of the S&P 500 has been well above 10%.  With the S&P 500’s current 20-year annualized gain currently at just 8.4%, though, what will it take for the S&P 500 to reach double-digit gains on an annualized basis over a 20-year window?

For an idea, given the strong performance of the last ten years, a number of commentators suggest that the next ten years for equities will be weak with a reversion to the mean.  Only time will tell, but if we operate under the (unlikely) assumption that the S&P 500 stays at the exact same level it is now going forward for the next ten years, its annualized twenty-year return would top 10% for the first time since August 2008 next September.  After that brief period above 10% from September 2022 through March 2023, it wouldn’t again top that level until February 2029.  In spite of the fact that the annualized 20-year return would top 10% in those two periods, though, it still wouldn’t get as high as the historical average of 10.9% in either of those periods.  This reflects the fact that although the last ten years for US equities have been very strong, they also came shortly after one of the worst ten-year periods for US equities on record.  Click here to view Bespoke’s premium membership options.