Homebuilder Sentiment Unfazed

In every month from August through November, NAHB’s reading on homebuilder sentiment came in at record highs. That streak was bound to come to an end eventually, and it happened this month. The December reading released today was expected to decline from a record of 90 down to 88. Instead, the drop was even larger as the index fell to 86.  Although lower, that is still the second-highest reading on record dating back to 1985.

Each of the sub-indices were also lower this month with the declines in the bottom decile of all monthly moves, though again, the indices remain at historically strong levels in the top 1% of all readings.  For the sub-index that tracks present sales, just like the headline number, the four-point decline in December hasn’t done much damage as it was also still the second-highest reading on record.  The indices for future sales and traffic likewise fell an identical four points.  For future sales, the decline only brings it back to where it stood in September and the index for Traffic is at the lowest level since August. Those are the third and fourth highest readings on record, respectively.

The picture also remains strong based on regions in spite of broad declines.  While every region experienced a decline, the West’s was the smallest. Additionally, the index for the West is the highest of the four regions.  The Northeast, on the other hand, has the lowest reading for sentiment, though, it too is in the top 2% of all readings.

Elsewhere in housing data today, the MBA’s weekly mortgage application data showed another uptick in purchase applications.  Purchase apps rose 1.8% week over week, and while still off the highs from the last week of November, purchases are running at the strongest level in over a decade.

Even though this data remains broadly strong, homebuilder stocks have not been reflecting it.  As shown below, the S&P 1500 Homebuilders group has yet to take out its October 15th high, currently trading 11.51% below that level.  Since that high, the index has also fallen below its 50-DMA with multiple failed attempts to move back above. In fact, of the 43 trading days since that high, the group has closed below its 50-DMA on all but 10 days. While that paints a somewhat negative technical picture, on the bright side, the group has yet to make a lower low. Click here to view Bespoke’s premium membership options for our best research available.

Bespoke CNBC Appearance (12/14)

Bespoke co-founder Paul Hickey appeared on CNBC’s Closing Bell yesterday on Monday to discuss the market outlook in a post-vaccine world.  To view the segment, click on the image below.

B.I.G. Tips – Wretched Retail Sales

If Congress was looking for any evidence that additional relief for Americans was needed, the November Retail Sales report should provide some ammunition. At the headline level, Retail Sales fell 1.1%, which was nearly four times the decline of consensus forecasts. Stripping out Autos and Gas, the numbers were just as bad. As if that wasn’t enough, October’s report was also revised significantly lower dropping from a gain of 0.3% at the headline level to a decline of 0.1%. Adding it all together, Retail Sales for November were 1.5% lower than what was originally reported in October’s report.

Breadth in this month’s report was also weak. Of the thirteen sectors that comprise the total pie, all but three of them were lower on the month. If you were expecting a new sweater this Christmas, don’t hold your breath as sales of Clothing were down close to 7%. Other big decliners included Bars & Restaurants (-3.99%) and Electronics & Appliances (-3.49%). With more cities imposing restrictions on activity, sales at Gas Stations also declined 2.41%. Were it not for the historic declines we saw earlier this year, drops of this magnitude would be considered pretty steep, but after the COVID shutdowns, nothing is a surprise anymore. Not every aspect of the Retail Sales report was weak, though. Bright spots included Food & Beverage Stores, Building Materials, and Online– all sectors you would expect to see hold up well as Americans hunker down.

The characteristics behind the total level of sales have changed markedly in the post-COVID world.  In our just-released B.I.G. Tips report, we looked at these changing dynamics to highlight the groups that have been the biggest winners and losers from the shifts.  For anyone with more than a passing interest in how the COVID outbreak is impacting the economy, our monthly update on retail sales is a must-read.  To see the report, sign up for a monthly Bespoke Premium membership now!

Bespoke’s Morning Lineup – 12/16/20 – Big-Coin

See what’s driving market performance around the world in today’s Morning Lineup.  Bespoke’s Morning Lineup is the best way to start your trading day.  Read it now by starting a two-week free trial to Bespoke Premium.  CLICK HERE to learn more and start your free trial.

“Buying’s easier, selling’s hard – [it’s] hard to know when to get out.” – Seth Klarman

On a day when the FOMC is scheduled to announce a decision on interest rate policy and Congress is attempting to hammer out a stimulus bill, the latest data on Retail Sales is providing ammunition on the part of policymakers to go big.  Retail Sales for the month of November were weak on all counts both relative to expectations and on an absolute basis.  The headline index, for example, was expected to decline by 0.3% but actually saw a much larger decline, falling 1.1%. Later today, we’ll also get updates to Markit’s Manufacturing and Services Indices, Business Inventories, and Homebuilder Sentiment for the month of December.

Be sure to check out today’s Morning Lineup for updates on the latest market news and events, a recap of economic data out of Europe, an update on the latest national and international COVID trends, and much more.

ml0203

Along with just about every other asset priced in dollars, the price of bitcoin has been on the rebound in recent days, and in early trading today, prices are back above $20,000 to record highs. Again, as we discussed a couple of weeks ago when bitcoin was taking out its highs from late 2017, the latest run to $20,000 hasn’t been accompanied by nearly the amount of hype as there was back in 2017.  All those people must be too busy focusing on SPACs.

VIX Run Above 20 Tops 200 Days

With today’s close, the VIX has now stuck above 20 for 207 trading days and counting. That marks the fourth-longest streak since the inception of the volatility index, and is approaching the late-1990s and early-2000s record runs. The index was above 20 for 239 trading days through the end of June 1999, and 236 trading days through May 8th, 2003. Of course, from 2008 to December 21st of 2009, the VIX was over 20 for 331 trading days (more than a year).

Surprisingly, the current VIX streak has had an average reading higher than the two longer streaks in 1999 and 2003. The average 32.0 reading over its course so far is second only to the streak recorded over the global financial crisis. It’s also interesting to note that at this stage in the streak (207 trading days), the current run has a higher reading than the three streaks which actually lasted longer.

Not All Bad for the Empire Fed

The New York Fed kicked off the slate of December manufacturing data this morning with the release of the Empire State Manufacturing Survey. The release was expected to come in at the same level as last month (6.3), but instead, moved lower down to 4.9.  The index remained positive meaning the survey’s results were again consistent with growth, just at a slightly lower rate than expected. Even though current conditions have not been improving rapidly, respondents generally remain optimistic for the future.  The index for expectations six months out was slightly higher at 36.3. While higher, it is off the highs from just a few months ago still at more optimistic levels than were observed over the last couple of years.

Even though the headline index fell 1.4 points this month, breadth in the report was fairly strong. Most indices were higher relative to November with the only two indices declining being those of New Orders and Prices Received.  Meanwhile, only two indices—those for Unfilled Orders and Inventories—showed contractionary readings in December which is no different from last month.  Granted, both of these indices also showed less of a contractionary picture. Expectations readings for the same indices, on the other hand, were more mixed with around half lower month over month.

One of the two indices to decline in December was New Orders.  The decline was small though as the index dropped just 0.3 points to 3.4.  Outside of August’s contractionary reading, that is the lowest reading for New Orders in the past six months. Granted, the positive reading meant new orders have now risen for four straight months, albeit at a slower pace in November and December.

As New Orders continue to grow, Unfilled Orders are getting worked off.  The index for Unfilled Orders has remained in contraction for every month since April now. This month’s reading of -3.6 was the second-highest reading of that period behind July’s reading of -0.6.  The expectations index, though, remains much more optimistic.  25.7% of respondents reported that they expect unfilled orders to be higher in six months compared to 11.4% reporting they expect orders to be lower.  That resulted in the index rising to 14.3, the highest since February of 2018. The 9.7 point increase was also the largest one month move in expectations since November of last year.

With businesses meeting demand, inventories have continued to decline.  The index for Inventories has now been in contraction for nine consecutive months. Granted, this month saw the index move higher from -8.6 to -4.3. That means inventories have continued to decline but at a slower pace in December.  Similar to unfilled orders, there is also quite a gap between current conditions and expectations.  The index for future expectations rose to a reading of 15 in December.  That is the second-highest reading on record behind January of 2018’s high of 20.3.  In other words, even though inventories have declined for nine straight months, firms are not anticipating that to continue.  Nearly 30% of responding firms reported that they expect inventories to rise in six months’ time.

While there were more improvements in demand and inventories were lower, prices for inputs have been on the rise.  The index for Prices Paid rose 8 points to 37.1 in December.  Expectations for Prices Paid likewise moved higher reaching the highest level in two years. Prices Received are not experiencing the same degree of upward pressure though.   The index for Prices Received fell in December from 11.3 to 10 which is a much more modest reading overall. That is not to say it will continue to be that way.  Expectations for Prices Received rose to a reading of 30, the highest level since February of 2018.

In spite of the rise in COVID cases, the report’s readings on employment were pretty strong.  The index for the Number of Employees rose to 14.2 which was a two-year high while the index for the Average Workweek was unchanged at 4.8. So New York area manufacturers are not only hiring at their fastest rate since the end of 2018, but they are also increasing working hours. Click here to view Bespoke’s premium membership options for our best research available..

Featured Tools

Bespoke Chart Scanner Bespoke Trend Analyzer Earnings Report Screener Seasonality Database Economic Monitors

Additional Features

Wealth Management Free Charting Bespoke Podcast Death by Amazon

Categories