Bespoke’s Morning Lineup – 10/19/23
See what’s driving market performance around the world in today’s Morning Lineup. Bespoke’s Morning Lineup is the best way to start your trading day. Read it now by starting a two-week trial to Bespoke Premium. CLICK HERE to learn more and start your trial.
“I am not a politician… I only suffer the consequences.” – Peter Tosh
Start a two-week trial to Bespoke Premium now to get full access to the Morning Lineup.
With complete dysfunction in Washington, we’re all suffering the consequences of politicians. The continuing resolution keeping the government open expires on 11/17, and besides the geo-political turmoil around the world that needs to be addressed, the longer Republicans in the House go without reaching an agreement on who to elect as speaker, the more likely it is that we reach that mid-November deadline without a budget agreement. As easy as it is to complain about the incompetence in DC, though, Thomas Jefferson was right when he said, “The government you elect is the government you deserve.”
After a disheartening session on Wednesday, things aren’t looking all that positive this morning. Nasdaq futures are the lone bright spot following a positive reaction to Netflix (NFLX) earnings as the stock is poised to gap up over 13%. Tesla (TSLA), however, is moving in the opposite direction as the stock is trading down over 7% following a weak report that showed compressed margins and some downright somber commentary from Elon Musk. S&P 500 futures are essentially flat, and Dow futures are low.
Outside of equities, crude oil is trading down by about 1%, gold is slightly lower, the dollar is mixed, and bitcoin is modestly higher. The real action this morning, however, is in the Treasury market, where yields are higher across the curve with the biggest upside moves coming the further out you go as the 10-year yield is up over 7 basis points to just under 5% (4.98%). 5%!
On the economic calendar, jobless claims will be released at 8 AM, and are expected to remain right around the same levels as last week. Along with those numbers, the Philly Fed Manufacturing report will also be released at 8:30 (expectations are for a modest increase) and Existing Home Sales will hit the tap at 10:00. On the jobless claims front, initial claims were lower than expected while continuing claims came in modestly ahead of forecasts but at the highest level since June. Philly Fed was modestly weaker than expected and came in negative at the headline level for the 13th time in the last 14 months. Besides those numbers, Fed Chair Powell will speak at noon along with five other Fed officials throughout the day. Depending on their messages, it could be a pivotal day.
Admittedly, there’s not a lot of positives out there this morning, but we’ll give you two. First, while today’s date is October 19th, it’s not October 19th, 1987. Second, despite oil prices hovering near $90 per barrel, gas prices have been falling hard. As shown in the chart below, the national average price of a gallon currently sits at $3.565, according to AAA, and that’s the lowest price since July. You know what that means? More money to go inside and grab a bag of Doritos, a Big Gulp, and if you’re really adventurous, one of those things on the hot rollers!
Over the last month, national average gas prices are down just over 8% which is the largest 30-day decline of the year and ranks in in the lowest decile of 30-day returns dating back to 2005.
Sign up for a two-week trial to Bespoke Premium to continue reading more of today’s macro analysis.
Bespoke Baskets Update — October 2023
Daily Sector Snapshot — 10/18/23
Chart of the Day – Best Stocks on Q3 Earnings
Housing Starts Muted Relative to Expectations
Following Monday’s weaker-than-expected report on homebuilder sentiment, actual data on residential construction data in the form of Building Permits and Housing Starts came in mixed relative to expectations. While Housing Starts missed expectations by 25K (1.358 million versus 1.383 million), Building Permits topped forecasts by 20K (1.473 million versus 1.453 million).
The table below breaks down both reports by the size of units and on a regional basis. In last month’s report, the big miss in Housing Starts was due to a sharp decline in multi-family units, but they drove the 7.0% m/m increase in September with a gain of 17.6%. On a y/y basis, though, multi-family units are still down 31.4%. On the multi-family front, Building Permits picked up where Housing Starts left off last month with a 14.3% decline on a m/m basis and a 29.7% y/y decline. On a regional basis, the Northeast experienced the largest m/m decline in terms of both Building Permits and Housing Starts.
Taking a longer-term look at Housing Starts on a 12-month average basis, they continued to roll over in September. At an average monthly rate of 1.4 million, Housing Starts are well off the post-COVID peak from mid-2022 but are still above pre-COVID levels just below 1.3 million. So, on that measure and coupled with the spike in rates, one could make a valid argument that the level of Housing Starts has further to fall in the short term.
Looking at the 12-month average of Housing Starts and Building Permits from a shorter-term perspective shows that both indicators remain weak. While Housing Starts briefly stabilized this summer, they’ve resumed their downward trend in the last couple of months. Building Permits have been in a more pronounced downtrend where the 12-month average reading has declined for 14 straight months- the longest streak of declines since the Financial Crisis. Like Housing Starts, though, the current level of Building Permits is still above its pre-Covid peak.
Bespoke’s Morning Lineup – 10/18/23
See what’s driving market performance around the world in today’s Morning Lineup. Bespoke’s Morning Lineup is the best way to start your trading day. Read it now by starting a two-week trial to Bespoke Premium. CLICK HERE to learn more and start your trial.
“There are no rules here — we’re trying to accomplish something.” – Thomas Edison
Start a two-week trial to Bespoke Premium now to get full access to the Morning Lineup.
Oil is trading higher this morning after President Biden’s planned meeting with Arab leaders was scrapped after the bombing of a hospital in Gaza which each side is blaming on the other. At the margin, the trip’s cancellation raises risks of an escalation of the conflict, hence the rise in oil prices and lower equity prices. Normally, you’d expect to see treasuries rally in a situation like this, but they’re so out of favor these days, that they’ve only managed a modest rally.
Earnings season is finally kicking into gear, and after the close, we’ll get reports from Netflix (NFLX) and Tesla (TSLA), but this morning we’ve already seen notable reports which include Morgan Stanley (MS), Procter & Gamble (PG), and Travelers (TRV). Overall, results relative to expectations have been uninspiring as just over two-thirds of companies reporting this morning have exceeded EPS forecasts while less than half topped revenue estimates.
On the economic calendar, the only reports of note this morning were Building Permits and Housing Starts. Both reports came in close to expectations with Housing Starts slightly missing forecasts while Building Permits slightly beat.
Just when you think that European stocks are going to reverse their long-term underperformance relative to the US, US stocks start outperforming again. The last six months have been a perfect example. The chart below compares the rolling six-month performance between the S&P 500 and the STOXX 600 on a dollar-adjusted basis. While the two indices performed in line with each other in the spring, once Memorial Day arrived, US stocks started to pull away, and through yesterday’s close, the S&P 500 was up over 5% in the last six months while European stocks were down over 6%.
From a longer-term perspective, this trend is nothing new. The chart below shows the rolling six-month performance spread between the S&P 500 and the STOXX 600 ($-adjusted). Over the last 20+ years, especially since the Financial Crisis, there have been multiple six-month periods where the US outperformed Europe by an even wider margin (and far fewer periods where Europe outperformed the US by a wide margin). One major exception, though, was in the six months coming out of last October’s lows though April of this year. During that six-month period, Europe outperformed the US by more than 20 percentage points, which was the widest margin of outperformance on the part of Europe relative to the US since the Financial Crisis. It didn’t last long, though, and that period was more the exception than the rule.
The above quote from Thomas Edison is something to think about when you look at the trend of US outperformance relative to Europe. Sometimes, the more ‘rules’ you have the harder it is to accomplish things, and on the issue of regulation, Europe has a much higher burden than the US.
Sign up for a two-week trial to Bespoke Premium to continue reading more of today’s macro analysis.
Daily Sector Snapshot — 10/17/23
Bespoke Stock Scores — 10/17/23
Chart of the Day – Strong Breadth in Retail Sales
Rates Hit Homebuilders
Among industrial production and retail sales, the other major economic release this morning was homebuilder sentiment from the NAHB. As shown below, the October report showed sentiment slid down to a new multi-month low of 40. That was a four point decline month over month on top of the September reading being revised one point lower to 44. That marks the third MoM decline in a row since sentiment peaked at 56 in July. That leaves the index 9 points above the post-pandemic low of 31 from last December.
The drop in the headline index was due to broad-based weakness throughout the report. As shown below, every component of the headline number was lower month over month and is now in the bottom quartile of historical readings. Those month-over-month declines in October were also historically large, each one with the exception of future sales ranking in the bottom decile of all month-over-month moves. That would imply the nation’s homebuilders have seen significant deterioration in their businesses which the NAHB noted was on account of higher rates.
As for a regional look at homebuilder sentiment, each area also saw a lower reading month over month, however, there is a degree of variability in these readings. For starters, homebuilder sentiment in the Northeast is by far the healthiest with the October reading registering in the 58th percentile of all months since 2005. That compares to the next highest, the Midwest, which is only in the 38th percentile. Like the Northeast, the Midwest only fell by a single index point month over month, and that was dwarfed by the 7-point decline in the West and a 5-point decline in the South.
In addition to today’s homebuilder sentiment data, one week ago the NAHB also published its quarterly survey on the remodeling market. Here too there has been a significant deterioration in conditions on account of higher interest rates. While the headline index remains bolstered and sits above the pre-pandemic range, it has pulled back significantly and is at the lowest levels since Q1 2020. Future market conditions, however, are back in line with pre-pandemic readings. Remodelers are also reporting new post-pandemic lows of smaller backlogs and fewer appointments for proposals. This trend was also reflected somewhat in the September Retail Sales report where housing-related sectors have seen some of the largest year-year declines in sales.
In addition to homebuilder sentiment having taken a hit, homebuilder stocks have also pulled back. Since the high at the start of August, the iShares Home Construction ETF (ITB) has fallen 13.9% having recently found support at its 200-DMA. While the group has found support, the past couple of months’ downtrend remains firmly in place.
