Housing data has come in weaker than expected across a number of indicators over the past several months, and as we discussed last night in The Closer, the Home Construction ETF (ITB) is near its worst levels versus the broad market in 6 1/2 years. With home prices relatively high, mortgage rates rising, a lack of cheap land to build on in many markets, tight labor availability, and input cost pressures, it’s not a huge surprise that homebuilders are in trouble.

All of that said, it’s remarkable how concerned markets and pundits are about housing. Each month, the National Association of Realtors puts out an index that combines home prices with income levels and mortgage rates to deliver a bottom-line affordability number. The level of the index is arbitrary; what matters is the change or relative level. Higher readings mean housing is more affordable, lower readings mean housing is less affordable. Post-crisis, the combination of lower rates and home prices dropping much more than incomes ever did mean housing became rapidly more affordable. For those that were able to take out a mortgage (credit was obviously very tight, many households couldn’t qualify, and households were deleveraging anyways), buying a house was cheap. Since home prices bottomed in 2012, though, things have gone the other way. Relative to the immediate post-crisis period, housing is now pretty expensive. But it’s important to keep in mind that relative to rates and incomes, it’s much, much less expensive now than it was at any point from 1989 through 2009. It’s important to keep this fact in mind when reading commentary about how hard mortgage rate increases will hit the housing market.

There may not be a whole lot of them, but among the bulls that remain, they held firm in the latest week as equity markets attempted to regain their footing.  According to the weekly sentiment survey from AAII, bullish sentiment increased this week from 30.6% up to 33.9%.  While slightly more than a third of investors are bullish, this reading remains below the historical average of 36.7% that has been in place throughout the bull market.

While bulls may have been resilient in the last week, so too were the bears.  They held firm at 35.0% versus 35.5% last week.

Investors considering themselves neutral saw the biggest decline this week, but even this reading saw little in the way of movement, falling from 33.9% down to 31.1%.

Like its New York counterpart, the October read on manufacturing in the Philadelphia Fed region came in slightly better than expected.  While economists were forecasting the headline General Conditions index to come in at a level of 20.0 versus last month’s reading of 22.9, the actual reading of 22.2 showed only a slight decline.  As it stands now, the Philly Fed has been positive for 29 straight months, which is the longest streak of growth readings since the 30-month streak ending in August 2015 and before that the 29-month streak ending in August 1998.

Breadth in this month’s report was skewed towards the positive side as five components increased m/m and just four declined.  The biggest increase was in the Average Workweek followed by Shipments, while Unfilled Orders and Delivery Times saw the largest declines.  Prices Paid also warrants a mention, as even though it didn’t see a large m/m decline, it remains well off of its multi-year high of 62.9 back in July (chart below).

After reaching what was tied for the highest weekly reading (215K) since July last week, jobless claims fell slightly more than forecast, dropping from 215K down to 210K compared to expectations for a level of 211K.  Perhaps the most noteworthy aspect of the previous sentence was the fact that a weekly reading of 215K represented a three-month high in claims.  That’s just how low claims have been!  As for the streaks, the weekly print has now been at or below 300K for a record 189 straight weeks, been at or below 250K for 54 straight weeks, and at or below 225K for 15 straight weeks.

Even though claims declined this week, the four-week moving average increased slightly, rising from 209.75K up to 211.75K.  That’s still less than 6K from the multi-decade high of 206K back from mid-September, but based on the recent prints, it doesn’t look like we will be getting anywhere near that record in the near future.

On a non-seasonally adjusted (NSA) basis, jobless claims fell from 199.9K down to 190K.  For the current week of the year, that’s more than 130K below the average since 2000 and the lowest weekly print since the same week in 1969.