Bespoke co-founder Paul Hickey appeared on CNBC’s Power Lunch on Wednesday to discuss markets heading into September.  Please click the image below to view the appearance.

Most investors are trying to forget about August performance as quickly as possible, but we wanted to highlight a noteworthy data set about the month before it gets too far into the rear-view mirror.  At the end of every month, we run our decile analysis of the S&P 500 to see which stock characteristics drove performance the most.  One characteristic we look at is valuation, and in August, valuations played a big role in performance.

Below we’ve broken up the S&P 500 into deciles based on P/E ratios (trailing 12-month).  Decile 1 contains the 50 stocks in the S&P with the lowest P/Es at the start of August, while decile 10 contains the 50 stocks in the index with the highest (or negative) P/Es.  Each bar in the chart shows the average percentage change in August of the 50 stocks in each decile.

As shown, the 50 stocks in the S&P with the lowest P/E ratios at the start of the month fell an average of 11.5% in August!  The next two deciles with the lowest P/E ratios fell more than 5% as well.  On the other end of the spectrum, the 50 stocks with the highest P/E ratios fell only 0.78% in August.

You’ve certainly heard a lot about the “death of value investing” recently, and this is why!  We have to think that at some point the scales will tip and head in the other direction.  Start a two-week free trial to Bespoke Premium to see our full decile analysis report for August.

As with other defensive sectors and safe assets, Utilities (XLU) has been on a tear all year with a 22.2% gain.  The sector has been in a strong long term uptrend for some time now with the most recent leg higher bringing it to extremely overbought levels. XLU now sits over 3 standard deviations above its 50-DMA thanks to yesterday’s 1.77% rally.  In the past year, there have only been four other days with larger single-day gains: June 5th, May 10th, and January 31st of this year, and October 24th of last year.  Only the occurrence in June also coincided with XLU moving over 3 standard deviations above its 50-day in the surrounding days.

Since the Utilities Sector ETF first began trading in 1999, it has been rare to see XLU trade over 3 standard deviations above its 50-DMA.  In fact, of all trading days that the ETF has been on the market, only 36 have seen XLU close at this extreme of overbought levels.  Utilities do not stay this extended for long. The longest streak that where XLU has remained this overbought was 9 trading days in 2017; a majority of the time it only lasts for a single day.

Although it can be reasoned that extremely overbought levels would lead to some degree of downside mean reversion, historically that has not necessarily been the case.  As shown in the table below, performance following periods where the ETF closed over 3 standard deviations above its 50-DMA after having not done so for 80 days have actually generally held a positive bias.  Only in the following week has XLU averaged a decline, but median performance is positive with a 45 bps gain.  Returns are consistently positive one month, three months, and half a year later.  For both three and six months out, there has only been one occurrence each that XLU was not higher.  Six months later has been the strongest of these time periods, averaging a 7.63% gain. One year later, while still positive on average with multiple occurrences of double-digit returns, XLU has only been higher 60% of the time.  Start a two-week free trial to Bespoke Institutional to access our interactive Security Analysis tool and much more.

Talk about indecisive!  After a moderate decline to kick off the week yesterday, US equities have more than erased those losses today.  While a pretty big drop in the equity market followed by a big gain isn’t unheard of, when it goes on and on for more than a month, it’s enough to drive you nuts.  Ever since early August, investors are being whipped around by a series of contradictory tweets, headlines, and “reports”.  One day the trade war with China is at the point of no return.  The next day the two sides are talking.  It was only a couple of days ago that a peaceful solution to the protests in Hong Kong was almost out of the question.  Today, everything is copacetic as CEO Carrie Lam withdrew the extradition bill that caused all the protests in the first place.  On some days, Consumer Confidence, Retail Sales, Jobless Claims, etc suggest that a recession is out of the question, but then the next, reports like the ISM Manufacturing sector fall into negative territory.

Where does all the indecision leave us?  Since the start of August, the S&P 500 has seen a series of eleven different rallies ranging between 1% and 4%.  In between each of those rallies, though, we have seen ten different declines in the range of between 1% and 4% as well.  With all the ups and downs, the S&P 500 finds itself trading at a level right around 2,930, which is a level it has crossed above and below on an intraday basis countless times over the last month, and for that matter the last year. We’ve already heard a number of stories about how companies are putting off big investment decisions until issues with trade and the economy start to sort themselves out, and based on the last month, the market has joined them. Start a two-week free trial to Bespoke Institutional to access our interactive market tools and all of our analysis.