Earnings season is now in full swing, and we’ve already seen reports from seven of the largest and most significant banks and brokerage firms. While the results have been good, investors have been reacting with a sell the news attitude. As shown in the table below, all seven of the major banks and brokerage firms reporting so far have topped EPS forecasts. Revenues, on the other hand, haven’t been as positive relative to expectations with four beats and three misses. Where the real weakness has been, however, is in stock price reactions. Of the seven names reporting, five have either had or are on pace to have a negative one-day reaction to their earnings report, while just two – Bank of America (BAC) and Charles Schwab (SCHW) – are just marginally higher today in reaction to their reports. While these two stocks are higher, we would note that BAC was down 3% in sympathy with the other banks on Friday, so the only one of the seven listed that is at the same levels or higher now than it was at last Thursday’s close is SCHW.
With the seven stocks listed below all beating EPS expectations but averaging a decline of close to 3% in reaction to their earnings reports, we wondered how common it is for EPS relative to expectations to come in so strong in an earnings season but the stocks reacting so poorly. Using our Earnings Database and running some filters, we found just five other quarters in the last ten years where all seven stocks reported better than expected EPS. Interestingly enough, of those five periods, the average one-day reaction of the seven stocks in that earnings season was negative four times. The only earnings season where the seven stocks averaged a gain on their earnings reaction day was the Q4 2018 reporting period in January 2019. The worst reaction of these seven stocks in an earnings season when they all topped EPS forecasts was last earnings season in October when they averaged a decline of 2.95% with five of the seven names declining. It was only three months ago, but already last October seems like so long ago. Not a client? Click here to view Bespoke’s premium membership options including Bespoke Institutional, which provides full access to our Earnings Explorer tool.